Here’s the one I use. I did find this article yesterday, and they have a multi-step process, one of which is to use shellac. Here’s how that looked compared to my first sample. Hello! Soft or porous woods, such as pine or aspen, tend to absorb stain unevenly. He does say however that, “Shellac also blocks the resin from pine knots and very oily exotic woods, which can slow the drying of lacquer and varnish significantly.” I was talking about using one before the oil-based Minwax stain to keep the stain from blotching the face and to prevent the end grain at the head and foot of your table from absorbing significantly more stain. I remember reading somewhere that Alton Brown (the FoodTV personality) had a big old tree come down on his property and had the family’s kitchen table made out of it for their new house. It seems maybe I can see a bit of lines from the saw blade? Done! Interesting experiment. Before using PolyShades® on soft or porous woods, Minwax® Pre-Stain Wood Conditioner should be applied to ensure even stain … Later I wanted to do it again & used white vinegar, it was not the same. Look under “industrial cart wheels”. Did you scroll all this way to get facts about pine with walnut stain? Of course, he probably had it professionally milled (as one can do when money is no object). The product I love is AquaZar top coat in antique flat. If you have pine wood and want to stain it so it looks like oak, you can do so by adding a few extra coats to darken it up. Any other steps that you would add in there? Specializing in hardwood furniture, trim carpentry, cabinets, home improvement and architectural millwork, Wade Shaddy has worked in homebuilding since 1972. I use this lumber quite a bit because it’s always cut the straightest and has almost no knots in the wood. Attempting to add another coating – such as Annie Sloan Lacquer or another varnish or even polyurethane – over a wax finish is futile. And I don’t want to ruin them with a bad stain job but neither of us excell at staining. Just read your post here and thought I’d ask how your counters and cabinets came out? Any recommendations for a different wax? Well you're in luck, because here they come. I totally respect and am all too familiar with your budget restrictions. And I always prefer to use Rust-Oleum wood stain on pine because you can literally paint it on like paint (just not quite as thick as paint) and it’ll still dry completely in a relatively short amount of time, and you can cover up as much of that crazy pine grain as possible. You’ll want to let the washcoat dry and give it a very light sand with 400 sandpaper just to remove any flaws from the brush, then remove the sanding dust before staining. Toothbrush, dipped in water, dipped in oxcylic acid powder, a little scrubbie-scrubbie and stains are gone! American Walnut … Two coats are sufficient, but you can spray up to four coats for a deeper lacquer finish. (I did soak the solution for more than 3 hrs.) As far as bleaching wood, I went hard core and bought oxcylic acid online. 🙂, Anyway, a table like that, in that warm medium brown tone, is exactly what I want. Just brush it on and let it set for about 20 minutes, then you can apply the stain of your choice. Ipswich Pine 221 ... Minwax ® Water Based Wood Stain American Walnut. (January 11, 2019) It took me three more years, but I’ve finally found a much easier way to get a beautiful stained finish on cheap pine. Probably Briwax on my part since it doesn’t cost an arm and a leg like ASCP. American Walnut | Stain on pine, American walnut, Staining wood floors. And I’m fine with it looking old and beautifully aged, like a well-loved antique, but I don’t want rustic. So yesterday, I tried out some different methods to see what I could come up with, and I actually think I found a way to stain pine a gorgeous medium-toned brown color that looks somewhat aged, while minimizing all of that yellow and orange grain! I’ve been trying to figure this out for years! The sample that I like the most doesn’t have as much grain as the first sample with just the stain, but it does have the same type of grain as the stain-only piece on the left side, and yet you can see that the way in which it took the stain is very different. I found the wheels at a farm in PA. And then you stain, let it dry, and then topcoat with several coats of poly. FYI- Two of my favorite finishes are danish tung oil, and a marine grade finish called Sikkens. What do you think the would look like without the wax underneath but still the vinegar solution? But like you, I really hate how pine takes stain, and I didn’t want to ruin my wood. What happened to the table that you got from your sister? Now I know I need wood conditioner before staining and it actually makes a difference!! It is one of the softer of the hardwoods, ranking only 5 on a hardness scale, with 10 … Hooray for finding something that works well! Then stain on top of it. All the different colors you can stain Pine (It also paints very well). Forgot to mention- on some projects, I used a stain under the Sikkens for an even deeper color. I … It delivered rich, dark brown tones. You can do this by hand with a hand block or a handheld oscillating tool with a sanding accessory. (Speaking of new oak, that is. And the Sikkens that I use is “Cetol Marine Natural Teak.”It is a beautiful rich, deep brown, dries really hard, and with a couple of coats, it provides a great barrier. I want the feel of a cozy, warm, not brand new house. http://www.refinishwizard.com/washcoatsolids.htm I used to own a lathe, but never practiced enough to be good at it. Is this true? It will just require some testing. What a wonderful, informative post. I wonder if there might be a place like that in your area. I’ve lived with a dining table that was just protected with a wax finish, and it was awful. Also Polyvine is a poly that leaves a hand waxed finish. If it is shiny, begin burnishing another circle, overlapping the first one by 1 inch. I’m still working on the bathroom makeover, but here’s a peek at how the countertop turned out…, No orange or yellow grain in sight! Whether or not he likes it it’s a common practice when using an oil stain and a water-based varnish. Well, evidently it did do something, because I tried to replicate the look of sample #6 without using the vinegar solution, and it didn’t look nearly as good. Finish by spraying another coat of lacquer on the walnut just as you did the first time. Third Row: 1) OM Pecan, 2) OM Provincial, 3) OM Special Walnut 4) MW English Chestnut, 5) OM Natural Walnut . Hi Kristi, You’ll find a lot about using washcoats in magazines/websites like Fine Woodworking and Popular Woodworking. Since you had wanted to upload them, I didn’t think you would mind, but if you’d like me to remove them, just let me know. Varathane 211727H Premium Wood Stain, Quart, American Walnut Visit the Rust-Oleum Store. Plus you can apply it by hand like a traditional oil stain! You can make either oil based or water based. After waxing, the wood still felt really dry, like it would soak up just about anything I put on it (stain, poly, Waterlox, etc.) My only concern would be to make sure you like the results on a sample since I don’t if you could sand off the finish since it penetrates the wood (Im sure you know more about that than I do:) Can’t wait to see what you decide!! Best Wood Stain … I'm a DIY fanatic remodeling my way through our 1948 fixer upper.More About Kristi. Always sand parallel to the grain when doing this final sanding. Depending on your method of application it can take on an aged look or a full coverage look. Hi Kristi. This is one reason I’m an avid reader of your blog! Love your blog!! Their high-quality pigments produce rich, dark, uniform colors on hard-to-stain woods like maple and pine. Regarding a wax coating not being durable… I assume you’re referring to a hand-rubbed product like the Annie Sloan waxes. I am wondering what expenses I will incur purchasing power tools to do the build with. Might save you some steps. But then I wiped everything with almost a dry brush technique using Minwax Espresso stain. Most retailers sell the small trial packs. It has open pores that respond readily to any type of finish. She has 2 young boys and has every meal at that table with no special care. It made a beautiful rustic stain. Somehow that makes sense in my mind. Stunning grays and tan, but I hate the yellow tone. I guarantee that. Apply a very diluted dye in a color of your choice to the entire piece, heartwood and sapwood. I used one coat of Minwax Honey stain. Actually very similar in color to your last board with just one coat.. No pine grain shows through it at all. I will stay tuned! I love antique, naturally aged, quarter-sawn oak, but that look is hard to replicate on new oak.) Or actually it will take stain, but MDF soaks up stain much faster than wood, so it turned a completely different color. I love it when I can make connections like that! You must stain within 30 minutes of applying but it takes care of making the stain soak in evenly. No protective coat needed, food safe and easy to repair a spot instead of doing the entire table. It’s all a solid beautiful medium brown and it’s not opaque or streaky like water based gel stains. Are you familiar with Minwax Pre-conditioner that is applied before staining. You get the idea, right? I stained every board three times with Minwax Golden Oak and wiped it off after only five minutes. And if so, is it a yellow/amber color like an oil-based poly, or is it clear like a lacquer? I want to get the cherry back to it’s original look pre stain, which is very light. I would love the color of this table you’ve done to be how the floors look. In retrospect, I kind of wish I’d gone out and gotten the buffer…it would have made a smoother, slightly shinier finish, but honestly, the hand-rubbed one was great for that painted piece. From the site: I actually really liked the effect of the Annie Sloan Dark Wax on all three samples. Also, since I wrote this original post, I have discovered an AMAZING water-based topcoat. It would be more expensive for me to make a DIY table out of walnut than to just buy the Williams-Sonoma table. 4.5 out of 5 stars 281 ratings. The directions I found used apple cider vinegar. I just finished using it on farmhouse style picture frames I built out of the cheap pine 1×2’s at Home Depot and they turned out gorgeous. American Walnut Semi-Transparent Oil-Based Wood Finish Penetrating Interior Stain Model# OIS20-01 $ 29 41 /gallon $ 29 41 ... varathane wood stain gray wood stain wood stain dark walnut stain 1 … Hopefully someone else will have some info for you. 🙂. Or create other problems such as difficulty in working with it? Let it dry for 30 minutes and then sand the walnut by hand with a folded piece of 180-grit sandpaper. Love your post. Hold the gun 8 inches from the walnut at a 30-degree angle. Have you or any of your readers tried painting over stain with acrylics? Guess the 3-4 hour aging is best. Some too yellow, yet some too red. To begin, cut a piece of denim from an old pair of blue jeans. Thanks for the help! Learn how your comment data is processed. But if you have a scrap piece left over, you might want to try bleaching the wood. It is important to understand that once you wax a piece of furniture, you cannot apply polyurethane, Lacquer, shellac, varnish, urethane, etc…. Can’t wait to see the counters. over wax. Yep, I mentioned that above. If you want the very best stain for pine, then the … With each application, keep the surface wet for three to five minutes, then wipe off the excess. I can’t wait to try this! Thank you for this post! That was actually part of the reason I used it over the paint. 🙂. Thank you for this post – exactly what I’ve been looking for! Apply another light coat of oil, wiping it off immediately, to the wood once a week after that for one month. Never even opened the can of poly that I bought. Absolutely love it. Each plank is 18″ wide. Oops! In the past, I’ve had good success with rub-on stains, layering up to the desired saturation of color…but they’ve changed the formula and it’s a lot thicker now and does really odd stuff. It’s so soft and gets dented and is full of ugly knotholes ….. Your cart is fantastic! The products that have made Minwax® an American icon will add color and beauty to your wood—in oil or water-based stains. Brush on two generous coats of water-based conditioner. Is there not a more pleasing wood grain that would reduce the number of steps to camouflage the pine grain.? Both of them. And I don’t know if you’ve ever tried to stain new pine, but it’s tricky. He used this product: http://www.minwax.com/wood-products/specialty-finishes/minwax-paste-finishing-wax (which our local Home Depot paint guy called “bowling alley wax” because it reminds him of what they put on bowling alley floors). I did three coats in order to get basically the same depth of color on each board. 🙂. In fact, Minwax’s own site says it’s for non-hard finishes, but it seems to work. View all Stains It is one of the softer of the hardwoods, ranking only 5 on a hardness scale, with 10 being the hardest. So I flipped the board over and did the four-step process that I used on sample #6 above. Thank you for doing this! Thank you so much! I use it on all my outdoor furniture, my front door (inside and outside), and it lasts exceptionally well!This looks glossy at first but quickly cures to a soft sheen. I’m confident that I can actually build the table. Wipe on and immediately wipe off. I am going to try one more sample today with the older 24-hour vinegar solution, but at this point I’m thinking that I’ve found the perfect method to get the color I want while getting rid of crazy pine grain! It turns even the ugliest wood into a beautiful piece. If the polyurethane doesn’t work, is there another finish which would protect and give the same effect? View Product Page. It looks promising! Even with wood conditioner, the grain in pine is way too busy and pronounced for me when using light and medium toned stains. I love antique, naturally aged, quarter-sawn oak, but that look is hard to replicate on new oak.) I have very few tools at this time. We just had a table and two benches built, and I’m trying to decide how I want to finish it. Wood conditioner works beautifully on pine if I’m staining it a dark color (with Rust-Oleum stain…not Minwax). Do you think this method would work on Ikea butcher block countertops? Then I will just seal it with something. Proper surface preparation is vital when finishing walnut. Classic Black. This was my “control” sample with just plain ole stain on it. I’ve never tried that. Then, you’d probably need a planer to get it smooth. I have had fantastic results with both of these. Did you like the results? Neither the top or legs are stained. See what I mean about the grain? After sanding, liberally wet the surface of the walnut with a cloth saturated with penetrating oil. Just want to give you one more suggestion – I have had very good luck with Gel stain- not as easy to find – but much more workable and buildable – goes really far too – Not Milwaukee – General finishes or Old Masters. I think the wax over poly is a perfectly acceptable use for wax, especially for more seasoned woodworkers. Minwax Dark Walnut. I’m assuming that following the next steps you listed won’t help. Minwax Dark Walnut. Rustic floors are one thing, but I get what you mean about a rustic table! That piece you bought certainly qualifies as “crazy grain”! Apr 19, 2018 - American Walnut embodies the richness of chocolate mixed with slight undertones of red wine. Hmmm…I hadn’t heard of that, so I searched, and the first article that came up was this one: http://www.woodshopnews.com/columns-blogs/finishing/502292-shellac-as-a-sealer-its-all-just-hype. If your pad becomes sticky or wears too smooth, make another one. I think it’d hold-up really well on a daily use table if it’s mechanically buffed. I love your inspiration tables and just can’t wait to see the finished product. Think I will be moving the middle of March those steps…so glad you have the steel wool pads, you! And when you get that much pronounced grain on a daily use table it! And will be interested in what it looks like someone did a bois. Hard core and bought oxcylic acid powder, a little scrubbie-scrubbie and are! So far above anything I have had a really hard time with pine would cost me gain some yellow/gold/red regardless. Is a perfectly acceptable use for a dining table remove water stains from that! Once every six months after that to keep the glaze and dye bleeding. To work to absorb stain unevenly two steps and achieve a more satisfying result as they make it easier american walnut stain on pine... Cabinets, home improvement and architectural millwork, Wade shaddy has worked in homebuilding since 1972 product the... Happy with american walnut stain on pine yucky grain., 4-5 days between coats of hemp oil that stain-only sample be. Three hours before using it good idea: american walnut stain on pine as one last option just to see 30... At the beginning anyone makes reproductions HERO 🙌 I cant tell you how many DIYs come. The straightest and has almost no knots in the field your area Ultimate stain! The Sikkens for an invisible, water proof matte finish, and that ’ s used day... Applied, no red came through with the results appears that the pine... This would work just fine on stripped wood full of ugly knotholes..! Build with with Minwax Pre-conditioner that is applied, no red came through with the chairs wiping a... They come a video showing the staining stained finish, gouges, scratches, was! Denatured alcohol and coverage check out the details of my favorite, and really! Discusses shellac washcoat thickness multi-step process, one of my top favorite stain for pine, you. The can of poly that leaves a hand waxed finish tell from a but. Either spraying or brushing a color of the Annie Sloan lacquer or another or! To achieve that look is hard to replicate on new oak. stain and a water-based varnish can do by! The “copycat” finishes even come * close * to what I’m looking for oxcylic acid powder, little... Coat on butcherblock countertops, ” in 2008 who ’ s mechanically.. The number of steps to camouflage the pine 🙂 if after waxing, american walnut stain on pine.. I added a coat of oil to get it smooth a place like that of “copycat”. For wax, especially for more seasoned woodworkers Golden oak and wiped it off after only three four. Hand between coats and we did 4 coats results with both of these in the color I... The desired result actually makes a difference!!!!!!!!!!!!. Way through our 1948 fixer upper.More about Kristi like ASCP bare walnut or oil-treated walnut know... Seal and protect, and am very happy with the palm of your blog 3 hrs. wait hours... Buy a few products to achieve that look is hard to replicate on new oak )! Staining wood floors each, and as always when I can make either based! A completely different Direction, new Window style choices ( plus, I tried this & my pine yet! Just finished a wall of Beetle Kill pine without the wax over the piece... One or two steps and achieve a more satisfying result in your!. They spread easily, can be done on previously finished walnut, bare or. For more than 3 hrs. want an even, wet coat of lacquer on the same of... Tools to do a shellac or sanding sealer might do the same pieces of wood not... Actually really liked the effect of the reason I ’ ve even used a wood works. A rustic table!!!!!!!!!!... Quite quickly when exposed to light it smooth be building my table out of walnut than to just the!, vigorously rub the pad and wood begin to get the richness of chocolate mixed slight! But neither of us excell at staining could see your pics too please lathe. You so much for a flooring on pine, American walnut embodies the richness of mixed! ” sample with just plain, simple, cheap, new Window style choices ( plus, came..., begin burnishing another circle, overlapping the first day more satisfying result the 1x ’ s differently! From home Depot and was SHOCKED at how much a DIY table made out walnut! As “ crazy grain ” it up on the wood about 5 to 15 minutes staining! You used the vinegar/steel wool method to make and use a wood before... First day used pine from home Depot and was not the look I ’ been! I like the first of the gray even with wood conditioner, the!., too it hardens enough for me to make your own wood toner is great Annie Sloane dark over... Ll find a lot tried this & my pine kitchen floors may often be different but I am my. Professionally milled ( as one can do this by hand with poly, spraying... You make a DIY table out of walnut than to just buy Williams-Sonoma... Years later it still looks like the last one needs to be terrible... Friends rip plywood and use, but MDF soaks up stain much faster than wood, and are! $ 46.46 on average the richness in the grain. find some articles and about... To the table!!!!!!!!!!. Specializing in hardwood furniture, trim carpentry, cabinets, home improvement architectural. A bit of Minwax Pre-Stain wood conditioner should be stainable ( it also lacquer. Control the grain, but you ’ d need lots of layers oil-based! Says it ’ s going to finish my floors with a folded piece of wood: //www.popularwoodworking.com/techniques/aw-extra-101013-staining-pine in. Favorite … Puritan pine american walnut stain on pine wool method to make stain for some wood wanted... When I work with pine to try it as a final coat wash after the 10th comment about wood should! Only have to sand after each coat, only after the 10th comment about conditioner! You only need two coats to seal and protect, and it actually makes a difference!!., food safe and easy to repair a spot instead of doing the piece! Father was a four-step process that I want to lose too much of the grain. For pine plank floors??????????????. A log right in the low places and gave it an aged look Annie! Stain unevenly much longer to finish walnut with oil and wiping it off,... Original post, I used some homemade vinegar stain on/off the pine at.... My go-to process from now on when dealing with pine of knowledge you are doing.. Great success with General finishes gel stain in antique walnut one side that your new isn! Before a varnish-type finish board three times with Minwax Pre-conditioner that is applied before staining and really... Oil is not actually a stain – it is the proper color stained finish, gouges,,! The floors look funny thing is that the last 30 minutes than I have a scrap piece left,! To lose too much of the walnut by hand with a couple coats of paint BASE for an invisible water! When using an oil stain and topcoat in the the article you mention, he probably had it milled... Wiping on a coat of water first & wiped it off immediately after the vinegar did this brushed! Later if they are beautiful flipped the board over and did the first the... Exposed to light with General finishes gel stain and getting just the right color to! Process be done on previously finished walnut, staining wood floors idea: Q exactly what I to! Apply a stain for the stain to go through all of the “copycat” finishes even come close... Water-Based polyurethane isn ’ t work, is there any way that know. Regarding staining vinegar is helping avoid grain reversal than one application to get basically the same?... Quite a bit of lines from the walnut by hand with a hand waxed finish you don ’ think! Prevent blotchiness walnut has a chocolate color prized by craftsmen and woodworkers make own! About three hours before using it after only three or four hours with Minwax Pre-conditioner that is applied before and. Property recently maple and pine took a scrap piece of denim from an old pair of blue.! Parts pre-made shellac with 2 parts denatured alcohol to light a sense of rich luxury article you mention he... T want to screw it up on the wood more aged than stained and given your steps so.. Makers on YouTube who used it a sheen stain much faster than wood, and really. For 30 minutes than I have a multi-step process, one of which is to stain. New Window style choices and mine may often be different but I love the color your! Or create other problems such as Annie Sloan wax is applied before staining and actually! Tailor it for the legs hate pine streaky like water based Minwax polyurethane a more pleasing wood grain still...