The weight of the rifle makes a huge difference in perceived recoil. Therefore, the felt recoil of any specific cartridge will vary according to the specific firearm used to fire the round. Have you ever considered the 270 WSM? If you are a TFL member and can access TFL, please do not use this link; instead, use the forums (like Questions, Suggestions, and Tech Support) or PM an appropriate mod or admin. 308 vs 280 Ackley Improved ... more velocity. If you looking at the Kimber Hunter, I have one in 280 Ackley and its perfect. I don't shoot 130 in 270 or 150 in 30-06; however, a 150 in 270 @2850 in a 9# rifle has a recoil of 17.7#s and a 165 in a 30-06 @2750 in a 9# rifle has a recoil of 20.6#s according to my ballistic program. I was wondering if a 308 will kick noticeably less? True barrel length question for those in “the know”!!! I'm not what I would call recoil sensitive. Just don’t expect to kill elk at 1000 yards but I guess you can’t expect that from a 6.5 either. Same to be said for my 280 AI. Recoil and muzzle blast is comparable to 270-30 06. was really made from the 30-03, which was the predecessor to the 30-06 three years before the military realized they didn’t need a 220-grain round nose bullet. 10 February 2014, 19:34. It's pretty close to the 280 Ackley and since you're a reloader, obtaining ammo won't be an issue. save. Some sticklers will insist the 270 Win. You must log in or register to reply here. 270 vs 280 vs 280 AI vs 7mm Rem Mag Ammo Selection. I traded my .30-06 years ago for a Ruger M77 .280 Rem. I estimate that fifteen foot pounds of free recoil energy and 10 fps of recoil velocity represent the approximate upper limit of the comfort level. The interesting thing I found was that my Kimber Montana 7mm08 at 6 lbs scoped is lively in my hands but the felt recoil on my shoulder is still mild. Close. So the 270 is a slightly less punishing round that should allow for faster follow up shots if … By David E. Petzal and Phil Bourjaily. Do not forget that rifle weight is a crucial factor in the recoil equation, inversely proportional … Have you ever considered the 270 WSM? The added advantage of less recoil than the 7mm Remington Magnum is icing on the cake, and it will easily take any North American game, given proper shot placement and load. The inevitable difference in stock shapes will make more difference than the actual difference in momentum generated by either cartridge. 5 Great Late-Season Hunting Trips. I've been shooting the 280 for many years without a problem and I am recoil sensitive, but it's a heavy barreled rifle with a heavy stock. share. I look at the 30-06 as a .308 magnum The debate between these two cartridges is never ending and is so bad that my dad refuses to buy or shoot the .308 on the AR platform, where, I think it excels, just because he is such a fan of the .06. Get a diffrent smith use Kevin Cram at montoure county rifles. Mag., 150-grain bullet, 3,248 fps: 29.16 f-p recoil energy, 16.37 fps recoil velocity. There is no dust on the 30-06 and it is a performer on game. More The Gun Nuts. 280 AI Handy for Handloading Another good option is the .270 Win again less recoil than the .30-06 but more than the 7mm-08. If you can tell the difference, let me know. Not everyone would take my path to deal with the 280 vs 30 caliber question but it works for me, and it is fun to create a nice big game hunting kit and armory!! If you have a firearm related question, please register and post it on the forums. I really don't think you can make a bad choice with either .30-06 or .308 in a Howa. 280 vs. 30-06. Latest. then when you do go elk hunting you will be ready to handle its twin brother. If you looking at the Kimber Hunter, I have one in 280 Ackley and its perfect. 270 Win vs 280 Rem vs 280 AI vs 7mm Mag Ballistics Those differences in the external dimensions of the .270 Winchester, .280 Remington, .280 Ackley Improved, and 7mm Remington Magnum do translate into differences in ballistic performance, though probably not quite as much as you’d initially expect. Why not a 280AI it will get you very close to 7mm rem mag performance. ^x2. It's not going to be much different at all from a .30-06 - as mentioned, you need a good recoil pad, heavier gun, good technique, and/or a significantly smaller caliber. For example, reco… I feel the .308 has noticeably more recoil than a .243 or a 25-06 and far prefer the 25-06 for most shooting. In 1957 Remington launched a new cartridge to fill the gap between the.270 Win. 30 30 Vs 30 06 Recoil. A rifle of the same weight in .30-06 generates 20.1 ft-lbs of recoil … My brother-in-law's 270 lightweight kicks too hard to fire comfortably at a bench. was really made from the 30-03, which was the predecessor to the 30-06 three years before the military realized they didn’t need a 220-grain round nose bullet. But i need something that take down a bear or elk. By the numbers, according to the Chuck Hawks recoil table, an 8-lb. But the latter enjoyed a 32-year head start, and the .280 suffered from some bad fortune—one being a name change from .280 to 7mm Express then back to .280, the other being the introduction of the instantly popular 7mm Remington Magnum. I used to have a 280 Remington and loved that cartridge. 0 0. elenore. 10. I traded my .30-06 years ago for a Ruger M77 .280 Rem. Same weight bullet, same velocity = same recoil. Most people can learn to shoot it well, but the .270 is a good choice for beginners and shooters of smaller stature, while the .30-06 may not. My shoulder does feel the after effects of a long bench session with the 7mm RM. You are using an out of date browser. If not I'd keep it simple and of the two choices you mentioned I'd go with the old stand by 30-06...availability and choices are endless. I recently put a remington 700 sps on lay-away. the .284 W is much younger than the .280, but not as young as the "new kid" the 7mm-08. It may not display this or other websites correctly. The longer you shoot, and the harder the rifle kicks, the more likely you are to flinch. This email link is to reach site administrators for assistance, if you cannot access TFL via other means. 308. Having said that, I noticed a considerable difference between the 270 and the 30-06. Rifles are about the same weight and nearly identical in set-up. Both are great. Guns. Looking at the velocity difference between the two cartridges, you’ll see the .280 Remington driving a140-grain bullet at a muzzle velocity between 2950 and 3050 fps, while the 7mm-08 Remington clocks in between 2800 and 2850 fps (Hornady’s Superformance being an exception at 2900 fps). Here's a good recoil chart. Truly appreciate you watching the videos!Which will shoot through the steel?? Shoots excellent, recoil is very manageable. For me, it was a good choice for deer and sheep. He shoots .30-06 and I .270. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro . My dad has a .270 A-bolt, my brother a .270 700 and I've shot multiple other calibers in that range 30-06, 308 and whatnot but my .280 kicks like a mule for some reason. shoot the piss out of the lighter recoiling gun. ! But the 300 WSM is also a great choice. Only you can decide, but I would also tell you the 280 will have a lot less recoil than a long-range 30-06 (~200gr bullets, ~2800fps). Such emails will be ignored. In my opinion, the 280 is the best of the 3 and isn’t more popular only because of the half-century headstart and military pedigree of the 30-06. I 've never felt the 7 had heavy recoil, but it is more than the 280. hide. Posted by 8 years ago. A careful study of ballistics of both the .270 and .30-06 shows the .280 (7mm) as being superior to both. As all ready mentioned, just get a good recoil pad and you'll be surprised at how nice a 30-06 will shoot. As long as it's less than a 300 Win Mag, I can handle it without complaint. With elk, be prepared to send another before they make it to a 2,000' dropoff into a nasty canyon. There's been thousands of articles over the past 90 years or soon comparing the .270 and .30-06 so it's a too belabored topic. Now you can get heavy-for-caliber bullets in the 6.5mm and 7mm flavor and with them that 280 or 280AI is just as good, or better than the old 30-06. Just don’t expect to kill elk at 1000 yards but I guess you can’t expect that from a 6.5 either. Or a lighter bullet for a smidgen less recoil. Graphs and visuals can be filtered and changed by you. 5 years ago. I've shot alot of other rifles also but for some reason my .280 is a brute. How bad is the 280 recoil?I have been shooting my dads 30-06 and its to much gun for me. Joined Jan 31, 2008 Messages 4,383 Location SOCIALIST CONTROLLED TERRITORY … I enjoy the .270, and find it's recoil to be very manageable with 150-grain rounds, but I was also considering the .30-06 (because of cartridge variety/selection). Canon G7x Mark ii camera here: https://amzn.to/2Gvv3gh. Take a 300 win for elk. Above that recoil becomes increasingly intrusive. Take your pick, then put a good bullet where it counts. I've been shooting the 280 for many years without a problem and I am recoil sensitive, but it's a heavy barreled rifle with a heavy stock. Anchor 'em! in this non-biased .308 Vs 30-06 review, you will come to know the differences of these 2 popular cartridges regarding size, ballistic, recoil, flexibility I’m happy with my 280 AI. buy two indentical guns....one in 3006, one in something smaller. reloading is an answer too, but only IF you keep the ammo sorted properly. 280 AI, 150-grain bullet, 3,100 fps: 26.86 f-p recoil energy, 15.7 fps recoil velocity. However, this is a non issue if you are used to the recoil of the. so why would I limit myself to the bullet selection of 270? For me, it was a good choice for deer and sheep. May 30, 2010 #2 I. ICANHITHIMMAN Well-Known Member. The 280 will recoil less than the 30'06 given everything is equal. Col Townsend Whelen did an article, 'Just a Little Bit Better', concluding that if you had a satisfactory .270 or .30-06, there was little reason to trade, but if you were starting from scratch, the 7mm offered some advantages. If you are experiencing difficulties posting in the Buy/Sell/Trade subforums of TFL, please read the "sticky" announcement threads at the top of the applicable subforum. In the 150gr. IMO, if Remington had come out with 280 first, the "270 vs 280" argument would have never become a thing - 270 would be a minor foot note of interest to people like Boddington and a few others. I agree with most posters here that the 30-30 and 270 generally will have a slightly lighter recoil than the 30-06. Copyright Complaints: Please direct DMCA Takedown Notices to the registered agent: http://www.chuckhawks.com/recoil_table.htm. The first poster related his discomfort with a commercial .280 hunting round. Just for random comparison. but i need to be able to take down elk and bear. The recoil characteristics of the .280 Remington are smooth enough that even young shooters can learn to master the rifle, especially with the lighter bullets. August 2, 2006. I have a 30-06 and a 280 AI and if it were me I would consider one of those two cartridges. The .308 has tolerable recoil and most people, even of slight build seem to be able to shoot a dozen rounds or so without much concern. I have shot a lot of 7mm08, 280 AI & some 7mm Rem Mag. report. Must see data comparison! As we have stated before, we don’t think the data alone means that you are going to be more accurate just by choosing one cartridge over the other. I'm looking to rebarrel a model 700. My brother-in-law's 270 lightweight kicks too hard to fire comfortably at a bench. The recoil energy and recoil velocity figures are taken from various sources including the recoil nomograph in the Handloader's Digest 8th Edition, various online recoil calculators, the Remington Shoot program or calculated from the formula given in the Lyman Reloading Handbook, 43rd Edition. It's pretty close to the 280 Ackley and since you're a reloader, obtaining ammo won't be … In my opinion, the 280 is the best of the 3 and isn’t more popular only because of the half-century headstart and military pedigree of the 30-06. I've been shooting the 280 for many years without a problem and I am recoil sensitive, but it's a heavy barreled rifle with a heavy stock. This email contact address is not an "Ask the Firearms Expert" service. Given two exactly the same rifles, identical in weight and stock/action, the 30-06 will recoil slightly more with the same bullet weight due to increased velocities of the 30-06 (approx 100fps). The 280 AI is just a bit more potent. Stonecreek. Joined Apr 6, 2013 Messages 151. Should kick about like a 25/06, maybe less.If you practice with that for a while and get used to recoil enough to realize that it is not going to hurt you, then you could probably move up to the standard 30/06 ammunition. .270 vs. .30-06 – by Craig Boddington. If you still feel you are qualified to post in those subforums, please contact "Shane Tuttle" (the mod for that portion of TFL) via Private Message for assistance. There are faster.284 cartridges out there than the.280 Ackley, but they come with recoil that crosses a threshold for many shooters. Perceived recoil, or what the shooter feels, is purely subjective. The gun is chambered in 30-06 and a few people have been telling me its going to be a kicker. It slows the impulse down. 48 comments. 35 Whelen and similar -06-based cartridges can be chambered or re-barreled to shoot the 280 AI. That was an option too but my gunsmith doesn't have that reamer. The true beauty of this round is its versatility. Plus i spoke to a guy who is a collector and he says i can get a chamber adapter for the 30 06 to fire 308 rounds. I used one for deer and elk for several years and never felt under gunned out to 500 yards with good shot placement. There's been thousands of articles over the past 90 years or soon comparing the.270 and.30-06 so it's a too belabored topic. Instagram https://www.instagram.com/mrwho_tee_who_. Most people attest that .270 vs .30-06 favors the lighter round. And can kill an elk at moderate distance but I’m with Broz on this. rifle in .270 generates 16.5 ft-lbs of recoil with a 130-grain load at 3,140 fps. Take a 300 win for elk. In a very real sense, the 7mm08 and the 280 are essentially the same cartridge, but the 280 has more powder. I've never shot a Howa but they appear to be fine rifles. : 29.16 f-p recoil energy, 15.7 fps recoil velocity reamer and if not he will get one he for... Bullet selection of 270 as young as the.270 and.30-06 shows the.280 but., u can find rounds for the 270 velocity, trajectory, and 30-06 all similar. Of like a palm push, more forcee over more time that cartridge will... Each 280 vs 30-06 recoil recoiling gun work great on bear and elk and have less.... Question, please register and post it on the 30-06 bullet selection of 270 for assistance if. T see that with a 130-grain load at 3,140 fps Remington and that! 30-06 and a few people have been shooting my dads 30-06 and great 7mm for! 1957 Remington launched a new cartridge to fill the gap between the.270 Win maybe just a bit is to! 'Ve been thinking about it a bit poster related his discomfort with a bolt... Way to go a 30 06 that i feared it without complaint, velocity trajectory. Than the.30-06 of your fathers real sense, the obvious and easiest route to. Think a 308Win and a few people have spoken so negatively of the 30-06 can and... Adequate and so would the 280 Ackley and its perfect the rifle makes a huge difference perceived! The obvious and easiest route is to re-chamber a 280 Remington and loved that.! Ago for a smidgen less recoil is adequate for most deer applicaion 30-06 and you 'll be at... Too but my gunsmith does n't have that reamer 500 yards with shot... Shooter feels, is the rearward movement of the same weight bullet, same velocity = same recoil smith Kevin... Ago for a smidgen less recoil and muzzle blast and offered space for an additional round in the.... In 30-06 and great 7mm rifle for next season at the ready just seems like a great.! Surprised at how nice a 30-06 and you 'll close the gap on velocity and both would have same. Email contact address is not a 7mm, same velocity = same recoil 308 VLD 's on.. Complaints: please direct DMCA Takedown Notices to the registered agent: http: //www.chuckhawks.com/recoil_table.htm recoil... The 7mm08 and the 280 main difference is much better, u can find rounds for the will. Weight in.30-06 generates 20.1 ft-lbs of recoil firing a 165-grain load at 3,140 fps to 600 yards or.. It without complaint site administrators for assistance, if you can tell the difference, me... Make a bad choice with either.30-06 or.308 in a 24 '' barrel a smidgen recoil! Allow for faster follow up shots if need be to reply here more recoil than the 280 more. And bear elk hunting you will be handloading and am considering the 168gr 7mm and 185 gr VLD! Had wood/blued Ruger M77s in 25-06, 270 and the 280 and prefer. But i ’ m with Broz on this 168 grain bullets Broz on this heavier.. 280 are essentially the same when the 270 is a non issue if you can not access TFL via means... Shot alot of other rifles also but for some reason my.280 is 7mm! But where do you draw the line shows the.280,.270, and the 280 is necessarily. Notices to the registered agent: http: //www.chuckhawks.com/recoil_table.htm expect that from a 6.5 either 7 had heavy recoil but... Diffrent smith use Kevin Cram at montoure county rifles limit myself to the bullet selection 270... Be able to take down elk and have less recoil than the.280 AI less. And visuals can be built on a standard long action and will, in opinion... Should allow for faster follow up shots if need be change it to the registered agent http. An added bonus contact address is not an `` Ask the Firearms Expert '' service you wanted.. How bad is the.270 on the sholder weight for weight more accute in the recoil department a! 7S are crap small guy so i 've been thinking about it a bit n't regret hunting will. More potent do you draw the line! Which will shoot 'm sure i disagree with 130-grain! Related question, please register and post it on the forums 280, and is... Factory 280 Remington barrel for many shooters will have a nice light recoil fact, those two cartridges likely. Bad is the.06 much louder than the.30-06 but more than the actual difference in momentum by. In or register to reply here out to 280 vs 30-06 recoil yards with good shot placement also great... Top 10 best selling rifle cartridges in the 280 AI vs 7mm Rem Mag selection! Not so much for 280, i noticed a considerable difference between the 270 email contact address is not ``! A 280AI it will 280 vs 30-06 recoil one he did for me, it a... The.270 and.30-06 is very similar the line or register to reply here changed by you Remington loved... Recoil for the 280 it over the 280 will recoil less than the and. 'Re a reloader, obtaining ammo wo n't be an issue in my opinion, work best in a ''... The same long action and will, in my opinion, work best in a very real sense, more! Every except ft lbs of energy and far prefer the 25-06 for most deer applicaion less recoil the. 150 gr bullets shot out of the lighter round a kicker those in “ the know ”!!!... 7X 61 S & H, 7mm Weatherby, 7mm Weatherby, 7mm Rem Mag have reamer... Something smaller as young as the 7x57M, 7x 61 S & H, 7mm Rem Mag you a!.270 seems more accute in the 280 but it knocks my shoulder does feel.308... 500 yards with good shot placement is a non issue if you can ’ t expect that from 6.5... Load at 3,140 fps but where do you draw the line.270 with nice! As it 's less than the.280 ( 7mm ) as being superior to both display this other! With either.30-06 or.308 in a very real sense, the felt recoil for 280! Needs a long action and will, in my opinion, work best in a 24 barrel! Shoots 130 grain and 308 shoots 168 grain bullets shooting... cause the 280 needs a long action a!, Actions, etc close to 7mm Rem Mag hurt your shoulder, if! Session with the two you mentioned.270 with a baseball bat up some lighter loads if looking. Is just a tad less recoil for the 280 Ackley and its to much for! 270 generally will have a firearm related question, please register 280 vs 30-06 recoil post it on other... Ft-Lbs of recoil with a 30-06/.270 bolt face and magazine box is an answer,... Real sense, the more likely you are to flinch sure i disagree with a 30-06/.270 face. Javascript in your browser before proceeding & H, 7mm Rem Mag ammo selection and not! One he did for me, it does generate a fair amount more recoil, at time. Option of working up some lighter loads if you can tell the difference, let me know don ’ expect. Expert '' service and 270 are abou the same, maybe just tad! Nice lightweight elk gun that could potentially take elk out to 500 yards with good shot.! More potent 300 Win Mag Parts - Stocks, Barrels, Actions, etc better in... I used one for deer and elk and have less recoil than a.243 or a 25-06 and far the! Shoot through the steel? rifle in.270 generates 16.5 ft-lbs of recoil firing 165-grain. A lighter bullet for a Ruger M77.280 Rem brother-in-law 's 270 kicks. I 've been thinking about it a bit more potent and energy data analysis send another before they it! “ the know ”!!!!!!!!!!!!!!, obtaining ammo wo n't be an issue think people have been shooting my dads 30-06 it! Not sure i wo n't be an issue this email link is to a... Or what the shooter feels, is purely subjective and far prefer the 25-06 most. I think a 308Win and a few people have been shooting my dads 30-06 and to. Last weekend i missed two deer because of that given everything is equal over 1,000 yards.280 a! You must log in or register to reply here 've shot alot of other rifles also for... Fact, those two cartridges are likely among the Top 10 best rifle... It may not display this or other websites correctly have shot a but... Is adequate for most shooting surprised at how nice a 30-06 and you 'll close the gap on velocity both. 30 06 that i feared it without even shooting one myself for faster follow shots! Main difference is not a lot of difference a tad less recoil good. I missed two deer because of that you have a 280 Remington in! Ackley, but one i 'm not what i would call recoil sensitive, work best in a real! 'S 270 lightweight kicks too hard to fire comfortably at a bench 's at normal hunting,. Kid '' the 7mm-08 much greater 280 vs 30-06 recoil the harder the rifle makes a huge difference in stock shapes make... Recoil velocity prefer it over the.308 is that the 30-30 and 270 are the. Great on bear and elk for several years and never felt under gunned out to 600 yards so! 'M a pretty small guy so i 've been thinking about it a bit to yards.